KalshiSpy vs Predicting Top
Predicting Top is the better pick if you follow Polymarket as well as Kalshi or want short time windows. KalshiSpy is the better pick for Kalshi alone: it ranks by realized profit, lists every market each top trader won, and shows members the top 10’s live positions.
Predicting Top’s site describes live P&L rankings of Kalshi and Polymarket traders over daily, weekly, monthly and all-time windows, with a profile page for each trader.
How does KalshiSpy compare with Predicting Top?
| KalshiSpy | Predicting Top | |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | Kalshi | Kalshi and Polymarket, per its site |
| What it ranks by | Lifetime realized profit: settled and closed positions only | “Live P&L rankings”, per its site |
| Time window | Lifetime | Daily, weekly, monthly and all-time, per its site |
| Settled wins per trader | Every settled market a ranked trader won, with date, side and profit, free | Its site does not say |
| Live positions of the top traders | Members see the live positions of the top 10: market, side, size and price | Its site mentions open positions; it does not say whether that covers Kalshi |
| API and AI assistants | Ask in ChatGPT or Claude; API and MCP server on the Elite plan | Its site mentions a free API |
| Price | Ranking, profiles and settled wins free; live positions on a paid plan | Its site states no price |
Predicting Top: as its own pages described it on November 20, 2026. Sources below.
Where Predicting Top is the better pick
- It covers Polymarket too, so one site follows traders on both platforms.
- It has short windows, daily to monthly, as well as all-time.
- Its site mentions a free API.
Where KalshiSpy is the better pick
- KalshiSpy ranks by realized profit only, money made on settled and closed positions.
- Each ranked trader’s profile lists every settled market they won, with the date, the side and their profit.
- Members see the live positions of the top 10, side, size and price, with every name unlocked.
- You can ask KalshiSpy about top traders inside ChatGPT or Claude.
Which should you use?
Pick Predicting Top if: You trade on Polymarket as well as Kalshi, or you want a free daily view.
Pick KalshiSpy if: You trade on Kalshi and want proof of how the top traders made their money, plus their live positions.
Why you can trust these numbers
- lifetime realized profit of the top 10 together
- +$4.8M
- made by rank 1, @BWmarkets
- +$821K
- settled markets won by ranked traders since Jan 2025
- 7,468
-
Every trader is ID-verified by Kalshi
Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange, and nobody can trade on it until Kalshi has verified their identity with a driver’s license or passport. Every trader KalshiSpy ranks is one of those verified, one-person accounts.
-
Realized profit, not paper gains
The ranking is ordered by lifetime realized profit: money made on positions that settled or closed. Open positions valued at today’s prices do not count, so a lucky streak that has not paid out yet cannot lift anyone up the list.
-
Check any name yourself
Each ranked trader has a free profile here that links to their page on kalshi.com, where the name and the lifetime profit can be checked in a minute. Each settled win links to its market on kalshi.com too.
Try it with rank 1: open @BWmarkets’s free profile, then follow its link to kalshi.com.
Questions
What is the difference between KalshiSpy and Predicting Top?
Predicting Top ranks Kalshi and Polymarket traders by P&L over daily to all-time windows. KalshiSpy covers Kalshi alone, ranks by lifetime realized profit, lists each top trader’s settled wins and shows members the top 10’s live positions.
Does Predicting Top cover Polymarket?
Its site says it ranks Polymarket traders as well as Kalshi traders. KalshiSpy covers Kalshi only.
Is KalshiSpy free?
The ranking, every trader profile and the settled-wins archive are free. The top 10’s live positions are on a paid plan.
See who leads Kalshi today.
The top 3 are named free, with every market they won. Members see all ten names and their live positions.
See the best Kalshi traders →Sources
- Predicting Top, home page · read November 20, 2026